
WorkBuddy Stalled Processing a Batch of Interview Feedback — Did I Ask for Too Much?
I have a counterintuitive habit. On recruiting tool rankings, the one with the most complete feature list and the highest position is the one I'm least willing to click "try" on right away. Complete features means lots of config options, and lots of config options means you're on your own afterward.
These past couple days I came across that humaans.io piece, 24 best tools in HR for AI in 2026, listing a whole bunch by category — Agentic AI, performance management, HR helpdesk — and names like Workday, SeekOut, Eightfold AI, Paradox, HireVue, most of which I'm using or trying. My takeaway after reading was, seems like I'm still doing all this work myself. So I want to try WorkBuddy.
I want it to do something I have to do every week: gather the feedback interviewers send in scattered and turn it into something I can show the hiring manager. Wednesday afternoon I dumped five people's feedback documents in together and wrote a pretty long set of requirements — group by candidate, pull out the scores, then summarize the one thing each interviewer cared about most.
The first output looked pretty legit in format, but the content got crossed. Candidate A's evaluation had Candidate B's project name popping up in it.
I figured the filenames weren't clear enough, so I changed them to a "candidate-interviewer" format and ran it again. This time it only processed three files, the other two it didn't touch at all, and gave no notice whatsoever. I tried those two separately, and it popped a message to the effect of file parsing failed, check the format. But those two are just ordinary PDFs, I opened them myself and there's nothing wrong with them.
Is it that I dumped too many files at once, or that the requirements were written too long and it couldn't grasp the key points. Has anyone gotten this to run smoothly in a batch scenario like this, how many files at a time is more stable, and should the requirements be written in several goes or all at once. I'll try for another couple days on my end, and if it really doesn't work I'll fall back to manual grouping.
Physix Frontier